Elgin, IL
- Status
- Active
Current evaluation
Evaluated October 14, 2026
Rubric Orthodox Website Evaluation 2026, version 2
Core score13 / 30
Works6 / 15
Welcomes5 / 10
Connects2 / 5
Shares bonus+3 / 4
Overall16 / 34
Longitudinal record
Progress over time
1 evaluation
-
October 14, 2026Orthodox Website Evaluation 2026, version 2
13 / 30 +3 bonus
Complete record
Evaluation details
Open an evaluation to see every recorded criterion.
October 14, 2026Core 13 / 30 · +3 bonus
Evaluation framework: Orthodox Website Evaluation 2026, version 2
Interpretation: 2026-09-23. Findings and scores retain the rules used on the review date.
Works 6 / 15
| # | Point | Result | What we found |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Readable, scannable structure | No | Evidence · Tiny menu labels wrap across two rows above a large changing hero and dense three-column content, hindering easy scanning. |
| 2 | Focused navigation | No | Evidence · Fourteen primary menu items excluding Home far exceed the seven-item guideline. |
| 3 | Mobile usability | Yes | Evidence · Actual 390-pixel Home, visitor and office pages fit at 375 pixels. Menu opens and Welcome Visitors keyboard route works. |
| 4 | Mobile performance | No | Evidence · Lighthouse 13.4.1: three mobile lab LCP runs 11.25, 10.16, 9.94 seconds; median 10.16 seconds (exceeds the 2.5-second threshold). |
| 5 | Desktop performance | No | Evidence · Lighthouse 13.4.1: three desktop lab LCP runs 4.45, 3.33, 3.11 seconds; median 3.33 seconds (exceeds the 2.5-second threshold). |
| 6 | Basic accessibility | No | Evidence · Scan scores 74 and flags contrast, iframe titles, headings, image alternatives, labels, link names and lists. Tested phone menu and Email-field focus work. |
| 7 | Service times on the homepage | No | Evidence · Homepage embeds a calendar without a separately printed regular Sunday service clock. |
| 8 | Service times in the footer | No | Evidence · Shared footer links Worship Schedule but does not print regular times. |
| 9 | Contact path in navigation | Yes | Evidence · Contact is directly visible as a primary item. |
| 10 | Contact information beyond the homepage | Yes | Evidence · Shared footer email label opens the actual office message form. |
| 11 | Current public content | No | Evidence · Homepage Check Out Our Latest Events opens a newsletter dated January 1, 2025 with upcoming January events. Current calendar entries do not remove this stale latest-events presentation. |
| 12 | Address and directions | No | Evidence · October 13, 2026 clarification: footer address says 525 Church Road, but its map opens 535 Church Road. Actual Maps destination and correct parish address were verified. |
| 13 | Orthodox identity and locality | Yes | Evidence · Parish identity and Elgin locality are clear in the site and shared footer. |
| 14 | Discoverable by exact parish name | Yes | Evidence · Exact Google search returns the official site first organically and matching 525 Church Road address/phone panel. |
| 15 | Secure public access | Yes | Evidence · Inspected parish HTTPS pages open without browser security warnings. |
Welcomes 5 / 10
| # | Point | Result | What we found |
|---|---|---|---|
| 16 | Giving is not a primary invitation | No | Evidence · Stewardship and e-Giving Donations are primary items, and the opening also rotates a giving appeal. |
| 17 | Clear church identity and welcome at the top of the homepage | No | Evidence · Opening rotates between Welcome, stewardship and livestream messages. |
| 18 | Meaningful opening action | No | Evidence · Join Us in Worship leads to livestream links. Other opening actions are stewardship or livestream viewing, not a newcomer engagement path. |
| 19 | Direct welcome | Yes | Evidence · Homepage includes a Welcome message and a visible Welcome Visitors invitation, although the hero message rotates. |
| 20 | Authentic parish photography | No | Evidence · Prominent imagery shows an empty sanctuary, icons and livestream artwork rather than people participating in parish life. |
| 21 | Visit pathway on the homepage | Yes | Evidence · Welcome Visitors is visible on the homepage and opens actual guest guidance; shared Join Us also reaches it. |
| 22 | Visit pathway in primary navigation | Yes | Evidence · Welcome Visitors is a clear primary route to first-visit information. |
| 23 | Useful first-visit details | Yes | Evidence · Visitor page explains greeters in the narthex, a welcome card and help reaching fellowship hour after Liturgy. |
| 24 | Learn pathway in primary navigation | Yes | Evidence · Our Faith is a direct primary learning route. |
| 25 | Learn invitation on the homepage | No | Evidence · No deliberate homepage introduction-to-faith invitation was found beyond the general navigation; hero actions serve giving and livestreams. |
Connects 2 / 5
| # | Point | Result | What we found |
|---|---|---|---|
| 26 | Ask about the Orthodox faith | Yes | Evidence · Contact explicitly invites Orthodox faith questions and links to a visible office message form. This does not establish separate prayer, meeting or visit forms. |
| 27 | Request prayer | No | Evidence · Prayers in Time of Need provides prayers to read, with no guest prayer-request form. |
| 28 | Meet or speak with someone | No | Evidence · No guest meeting or conversation request form was found. |
| 29 | Plan a visit | No | Evidence · Greeters and a physical guestbook are described, but no online visit-plan or pre-visit help submission was found. |
| 30 | Encounter Orthodox teaching or parish voice | Yes | Evidence · Actual Welcome Visitors article explains apostolic faith, Pentecost and continuity, and invites guests from every cultural background. |
Shares 3 / 4
| # | Point | Result | What we found |
|---|---|---|---|
| 31 | Yes | Evidence · Direct Facebook link opens the verified Elgin parish with matching address, phone and website. | |
| 32 | Yes | Evidence · Direct Instagram account identifies Saint Sophia in Elgin and links the parish website. | |
| 33 | YouTube | Yes | Evidence · Direct YouTube channel identifies the Elgin parish and links the website; activity frequency was not scored. |
| 34 | TikTok | No | Evidence · No directly linked official TikTok account was found. |